How Much is Your Claim Worth?
How Much is Your Claim Worth?
Explore injury payouts made to actual Arizona car accident victims. Find cases similar to yours.
More than 51,000 people are injured and 1,000 are killed on Arizona roadways each year.¹
If you or a loved one are injured in a crash, you are entitled to pursue compensation.
The average car accident settlement for a moderate injury claim in Arizona is $20,847. Average payouts range from $5,019 for minor injuries to $212,832 for severe injuries.
We analyzed a group of Arizona lawsuits filed by plaintiffs injured in motor vehicle accidents. Each plaintiff received a jury award or settled their case before trial.
An extremely serious injury case from our group resulted in a payout of $7,225,000. This case was not included in the general average calculations so as not to skew the results excessively high.
Average Payout by Severity of Injury |
|
|---|---|
| Minor Injury | $5,019 |
| Moderate Injury | $20,847 |
| Severe Injury | $212,832 |
Payout Range by Severity of Injury |
|
| Minor Injury | $605 – $10,000 |
| Moderate Injury | $10,108 – $37,000 |
| Severe Injury | $40,000 – $1,670,000 |
Side-impact collisions, including sideswipe and left-turn crashes, are the most common type of traffic accidents in Arizona, followed by rear-end collisions.²
Average Side-Impact Collision Settlements |
|
|---|---|
| Minor Injury | $5,657 |
| Moderate Injury | $20,855 |
| Severe Injury | $239,265 |
Average Rear-End Accident Settlements |
|
| Minor Injury | $3,751 |
| Moderate Injury | $20,839 |
| Severe Injury | $102,333 |
Neck and back injuries are the most common injuries from all kinds of vehicle accidents, followed by head injuries.
This Arizona case group includes injuries ranging from mild whiplash to amputation to a permanent spinal cord injury. Victims of serious car accidents often suffer multiple injuries, including complex bone fractures, brain trauma, and internal injuries. Payouts are intended to compensate for all the victim’s damages, not one specific injury.
Most accident victims can expect to settle in the moderate payout range.
Average Neck and Back Injury Settlements |
|
|---|---|
| Minor Injury | $5,313 |
| Moderate Injury | $20,847 |
| Severe Injury | $195,386 |
Average Head Injury Settlements |
|
| Minor Injury | $1,000 |
| Moderate Injury | $24,350 |
| Severe Injury | $163,892 |
Arizona is a traditional fault state. You have the right to seek compensation from the at-fault driver for your damages. For most of us, that means filing a liability claim against the driver’s insurance company. You also have the option of filing a lawsuit against the driver.
If you’ve fully recovered from minor to moderate injuries, you may decide to handle an insurance claim on your own. For serious injury claims or complicated cases, you’ll need a personal injury attorney to get the best results.
Your attorney will find evidence to support a claim for all your current and future economic damages, like medical care and lost earning capacity. Your attorney will also pursue non-economic damages, such as pain and suffering and loss of consortium.
Juries, lawyers, and insurance adjusters base the value of a car accident claim on the severity of a victim’s injuries and related losses.
An easy way to estimate the value of a minor to moderate injury claim is the “multiple method.” Begin by totaling your medical bills, out-of-pocket costs, and lost wages. Then add one to three times that amount to account for your pain and suffering.
The adjuster will accept a multiple of one for injuries that caused a minor inconvenience, like a day or two on the couch with a heating pad. A multiple of two or three can be justified when your activities of daily living were disrupted for weeks or months.
A moderate car accident settlement in Arizona averages $20,847. You can expect a settlement to cover your medical bills, lost wages, out-of-pocket expenses, and an amount to compensate for pain and suffering.
Arizona’s Unfair Claims Settlement Practices law requires insurers to make prompt, fair, and equitable settlements after liability has become reasonably clear.
In addition, Arizona has a two-year statute of limitations for injury claims arising from a vehicle accident. Adults must settle their claim or file a lawsuit within two years of the accident date.
No. Arizona is not a no-fault auto insurance state. You can file a lawsuit against the at-fault driver’s insurance company, or name the driver in a lawsuit.
Arizona drivers caught without proof of insurance may be subject to penalties starting at $500 and a three-month driver’s license suspension.
Arizona Rules of Professional Conduct prohibit attorneys from charging excessive fees. Personal injury attorneys customarily charge a contingency fee between 33 and 40 percent of the final compensation they recover.
Minor car accident injuries are usually soft-tissue injuries like bumps, bruises, sprains and strains. The stiff and sore victim may be out of work for a few days, but will fully recover in less than a month.
Type of Injury: Whiplash injury
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $605
Case Summary: Plaintiff was driving north on 32nd Street while carrying one passenger, she slowed her vehicle and was struck from the rear by a vehicle driven by Defendant. Plaintiffs filed a complaint alleging Defendant’s Negligence caused the collision. The plaintiffs sought damages for their injuries, medical expenses, property damage, loss of income, pain and suffering and mental anguish. Defendant claimed the plaintiffs’ alleged injuries and damages were caused in whole or in part by the negligence of the plaintiffs or third persons. He also asserted affirmative defenses of waiver, estoppel, laches and failure to mitigate damages. A jury found in favor of Plaintiff driver.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Zalewski v. Edwards, CV2007-011924
Type of Injury: Shoulder injuries-scapular winging
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $901
Case Summary: Plaintiff was driving her vehicle when she stopped at a red light at the intersection of the ramp and Raintree Drive. She was hit from behind by a Lexus SUV driven by Defendant. Plaintiffs filed a complaint alleging that Defendant’s negligent driving caused the accident. Plaintiffs claimed female Plaintiff sustained permanent physical injuries. Plaintiff’s husband claimed loss of consortium. The defendant responded by filing an answer that contested the plaintiffs’ injuries. The parties went before an arbitrator who awarded the plaintiffs $50,000. The plaintiffs then offered to settle for $30,000 – $35,000. A jury found in favor of Female Plaintiff, and determined her damages were $900.70.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Roberson v. Kreschollek, CV 2004-000395
Type of Injury: Whiplash injury-neck strain
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $1,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff was traveling south on Campbell Avenue and stopped at a red light. His vehicle was then struck from the rear by a vehicle occupied by Defendants. Plaintiff his spouse filed a lawsuit alleging either of the Defendants was driving negligently. The plaintiffs sought compensation for property damage, personal injuries, pain and suffering, emotional distress, mental anguish, past and future medical expenses, disability, disfigurement, lost earnings, the inability to enjoy day-to-day activities and recreational activities and loss of consortium. The defendants admitted negligence but disputed the plaintiffs’ alleged injuries and damages. A jury found in favor of Plaintiff driver.
Location: Pima County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Niemeyer v. Bettencourt, C2005-6996
Type of Injury: Whiplash injury-cervical and neck strain
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $1,500
Case Summary: Plaintiff 1 was driving near the intersection of Speedway and Swan in Tucson, Ariz., with his wife, Plaintiff 2, as a passenger when his truck was rear-ended by Defendant, who was also driving a truck. Plaintiffs filed a complaint against Defendant and her husband claiming the plaintiffs suffered possible permanent injuries in the collision and sustained medical expenses, lost income, loss of consortium and other expenses. Defendants questioned whether the plaintiffs were injured in the crash and if the medical treatment they sought was “reasonable and necessary” and appropriately charged. Jury found for Plaintiff 2, awarding her $1,500 in damages, but found for the defendants on Plaintiff 1’s claims.
Location: Pima County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Shelley v. Chapman, C20033459
Type of Injury: Back-neck; hand-wrist injuries
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $2,271
Case Summary: Plaintiff filed a lawsuit alleging Defendant was negligent in failing to obey a traffic signal and in failing to control her vehicle. She stated two other vehicles had already completed their left turn when the collision occurred. Plaintiff sought compensation for pain and discomfort, suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, loss of society, companionship and affection and medical expenses. She claimed entitlement to punitive or exemplary damages because Defendant’s actions were wanton, reckless and in conscious disregard of her rights, interest and welfare. Defendant admitted causing the accident but disputed the nature and extent of the plaintiff’s injuries. A jury found in favor of the plaintiffs.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Hunt v. Lindsey, CV2006-013274
Type of Injury: Back-neck; Hand- elbow and Foot-knee injuries
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $2,782
Case Summary: The Defendant who was traveling east on Doubletree Road, ran a red light at the intersection of Tatum in May 2001 and hit a 1967 Ford Mustang convertible being driven by Plaintiff. Plaintiff filed a lawsuit claiming Defendant was to blame for the accident and Plaintiff’s subsequent injuries and damages. The Defendant admitted the subject accident occurred but disputed the plaintiff’s claimed injuries and damages. Defendant raised the affirmative defense of contributory negligence to bar or reduce Plaintiff’s recovery from the lawsuit. The jury returned a Plaintiff verdict.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Dolan v. Robinson, CV2003-010388
Type of Injury: Whiplash injury-neck pain
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $5,000
Case Summary: A two-vehicle collision occurred at the intersection of 6th Avenue and 39th Street in South Tucson, Ariz. Plaintiff, claiming he suffered a neck, back and shoulder sprain from the accident, sued Defendant in the Pima County Superior Court about a year later. The plaintiff also said he incurred medical expenses, lost wages and property damage from the rear-end collision. Defendant contested the plaintiff’s alleged injuries and damages and questioned whether Plaintiff sought appropriate treatment. Jury returned a verdict for Plaintiff.
Location: Pima County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Ochoa v. Clark, C20041683
Type of Injury: Back Injury- Neck, shoulder and back sprain
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $5,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff was driving his vehicle on Swan at its intersection with Ft. Lowell in Tucson, Arizona. While stopped at a red light, Plaintiff was rear-ended by a vehicle operated by Defendant, who Plaintiff claimed was traveling 40 m.p.h. Plaintiff contended the incident resulted in lumbar and cervical soft tissue injuries. Defendants admitted liability, although Defendant driver contended she was traveling at only 20 m.p.h. Defendants denied causation, contending Plaintiff’s symptoms were identical to injuries he sustained in a motor vehicle accident 2 years prior to this incident. Jury returned a Plaintiff verdict.
Location: Pima County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Wewee v. Moreno, C334740
Type of Injury: Back injuries-Cervical and lumbar strains/sprains
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $5,758
Case Summary: Defendant and Plaintiff collided at the intersection of Silverbell Road and El Camino del Cerro Road in Tucson, Ariz. Defendant made a left turn, but allegedly failed to yield the right-of-way to Plaintiff’s vehicle, causing the collision. Plaintiff filed a lawsuit against Defendant claiming Defendant’s negligent driving caused the collision and his subsequent injuries. Defendant admitted an accident occurred but denied fault. The action first went before arbitrator who awarded Plaintiff $11,000 plus costs. Defendant appealed the award and the case proceeded before a jury. Jurors returned a verdict in favor of the plaintiff for $3,732 in damages. Plaintiff later signed a satisfaction of judgment for $5,757.82 following motion for additur.
Location: Pima County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Hammar v. Crandell, C20012287
Type of Injury: Back Injury-upper and lower back pain, neck pain and stiffness, headaches.
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $6,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff was a passenger in her daughter’s 2001 Nissan sedan when she was involved in a motor vehicle accident in June 2002. While stopped for oncoming traffic, Plaintiffs car was rear-ended by a truck being driven by Defendant. Plaintiff filed a complaint claiming the defendant’s negligent driving caused the accident and left her with permanent injuries and damages. Her losses included disability, medical expenses, property damage and lost wages, Plaintiff said. Responding, Defendant admitted the subject accident took place but denied he was the cause. Jury found in favor of the Plaintiff.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: McLay v. Pierson, CV2004-091230
Type of Injury: Back injuries-back & neck pain
Type of Accident: Head-on
Award/Settlement Amount: $7,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff was driving his employer’s pickup truck when he was allegedly hit head-on by a vehicle driven by Defendant. A few months later Plaintiff returned home while a burglary was in progress and was assaulted by a perpetrator with a knife. Plaintiff filed suit against Defendant claiming that he sustained injuries as a result of the defendant’s negligent driving and was still in a “grossly deconditioned state” three months after the accident and was therefore unable to effectively fend off his attacker. In her answer, Defendant denied the allegations and asserted several affirmative defenses, including that Plaintiff was also at fault for the automobile accident. A jury returned a Plaintiff’s verdict.
Location: Pima County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Hartman v. Tigner, C20030577
Type of Injury: Back Injuries; burns to arms
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $8,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff was driving his car west of Chandler and his wife was a passenger. Near the intersection of Chandler Boulevard and Kyrene Road, the Plaintiffs’ car was struck by a car being driven east on Chandler by Defendant. Plaintiffs filed a lawsuit against Defendant, alleging he negligently failed to stop when the light in his direction turned red, causing the accident and injury to both Plaintiff who alleged the passenger sustained serious injuries to her neck, back, hands, and arm that required extensive medical treatment. Plaintiff claimed loss of consortium. Defendant denied he was negligent. Jury awarded the plaintiffs $8,000 in damages and further determined that both Plaintiff and Defendant liable 50% at fault.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Strang v. Ferrar, CV2002-092971
Type of Injury: Neck and shoulder injuries
Severity: Minor
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $9,473
Case Summary: Plaintiff was driving his 1998 Chevrolet truck while carrying two passengers. Their vehicle collided with a 1998 Volkswagen driven by Defendant. Plaintiff and his two passengers reportedly sustained personal injuries in the collision. Plaintiffs filed a lawsuit alleging Defendant’s negligence caused the collision. The plaintiffs sought compensation for medical expenses and damage to the Truck. The defendant denied causing the accident and denied acting recklessly, carelessly and/or negligently. Defendant asserted numerous affirmative defenses including contributory negligence, comparative negligence, assumption of risk and failure to mitigate damages. Jury found in favor of plaintiff and attributed fault of 50%:50% to Plaintiff driver and Defendant.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Gonzalez v. Oefelein, CV2007-001259
Type of Injury: Back Injury-Lower back; Hand Injury-left finger; Leg Injury- right knee.
Type of Accident: Head-on
Award/Settlement Amount: $10,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff was driving a car owned by his father when he was hit head-on by Defendant, 69-year-old hotel builder. Plaintiff and his father sued Defendant for causing the accident. Plaintiff claimed he incurred financial damages because his insurance company paid $1,371.65 less than the car was worth. Plaintiff’s father also sought damages for lost of income when he took off from work to drive Plaintiff to physical therapy. Defendant denied liability. A hearing was held before arbitrator who ruled in the Plaintiff’s favor and awarded him $24,658.24 and $1,000.00 to Plaintiff’s father. A jury found in favor of the plaintiff in the amount of $10,000.00. Judge upheld the verdict and further awarded Plaintiffs taxable costs of $2,681.20.
Location: Pima County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Rottenstein v. Eigen, C20033912
Type of Injury: Back injuries-two herniated discs in cervical spine; Neck and shoulder injuries; left arm pain and radiculopathy; migraines,
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $10,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff’s vehicle was allegedly rear-ended by Defendant’s vehicle. Plaintiff sued Defendant for negligent driving and Defendant’s mother for negligent entrustment. Defendant admitted negligence but disputed the nature and extent of the plaintiffs’ alleged damages. The jury found in favor of Plaintiff. Judge awarded Plaintiff $1,264.64 in taxable costs; $900 for reasonable expert witness fees; $7,040 in reasonable attorney fees attributed to defendants’ appeal of the arbitration award; and prejudgment interest at 10 percent per annum beginning from the date of arbitrator’s award. Judge also ordered the defendants to pay the clerk $288.55 in jury fees and $75 in compensation for the arbitrator.
Location: Pima County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Travis v. Kleinman, C20012759
Moderate car accident injuries can involve more extensive soft tissue injuries, serious whiplash injuries, slipped or herniated discs, concussions, and simple bone fractures. Recovery may take weeks or months, interfering with the victim’s ability to work. Some victims are left with residual impairments.
Type of Injury: Knee and Back
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $10,108
Case Summary: Plaintiff and Defendant were involved in a motor-vehicle accident on May 7, 2004 at the intersection of Alma School Road and Riggs Road in Chandler. Plaintiff filed a complaint against Defendant claiming that Defendant’s negligent and careless driving caused the vehicles to collide. Plaintiff said she injured her left finger, right knee and lower back; suffered a right medial meniscus tear that required surgery; sustained pain and suffering; incurred past and future medical expenses; and lost past and future wages. Defendant admitted negligence but contested the nature and extent of Plaintifff’s alleged damages. Jury returned a Plaintiff Verdict.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Girard v. Gove, CV-2006-005593
Type of Injury: Whiplash-Neck and shoulder injuries
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $11,373
Case Summary: Defendant was driving his vehicle when he rear-ended a motor vehicle which in turn hit the vehicle Plaintiff was driving causing it to collided with the vehicle in front. Plaintiff filed suit claiming Defendant’s negligent driving caused the accident and her injuries including that her previously treated migraine headaches returned and were aggravated as a result of the accident. Plaintiff’s husband claimed loss of consortium. Defendant admitted he was involved in a motor vehicle accident with the plaintiff, but denied he was negligent. A jury returned a verdict for the plaintiffs. Plaintiff’s subsequent motion for additur was denied by the Judge who ordered judgment accordance with the jury verdict.
Location: Pima County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Hager v.Torgerson, C20020766
Type of Injury: Back injury-cervical, lumbar strain; Hand- shoulder strains
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $12,500
Case Summary: Plaintiff said he was traveling south in the curb lane on South Country Club Drive when his vehicle was rear ended by Defendant. In his complaint, Plaintiff alleged Defendant “failed to control the speed of his vehicle” and caused the accident. The plaintiff claimed he suffered injuries and pain and suffering from the accident and incurred medical expenses as a result. Defendants filed an answer admitting an accident occurred but generally denying the complaint’s allegations. The jury returned a verdict for Plaintiff who was also awarded more than $1,600 in costs.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Dybas v. Settles, CV2002-001907
Type of Injury: Back injury-lumbar strain, low back pain, neck Pain; Left leg pain
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $14,525
Case Summary: Plaintiff, 36, was taking his 6-year-old son and his 4-year-old daughter on an errand in his pickup truck when they were involved in an accident at the intersection of Greenfield Road and Pony Road in Mesa, Ariz. Plaintiff reportedly went to Lutheran Urgent Care in Mesa where he was diagnosed with a lumbar strain. The plaintiffs claimed Defendant’s negligent driving caused the accident; Plaintiff’s injuries, medical expenses and lost wages; and Plaintiff’s wife loss of consortium. Defendant admitted fault in the July accident but contested the plaintiffs’ claimed injuries and damages. The jury returned a Plaintiff verdict.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Purucker v. O’Connell, CV2003-091859
Type of Injury: Whiplash-neck pain and headaches
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $15,000
Case Summary: The Plaintiff was involved in a motor vehicle accident when her parked vehicle was struck by a truck operated by the defendant in the course and scope of his employment with the co-defendant. The plaintiff contended that the co-defendant was vicariously liable under the doctrine of respondeat superior for the negligence of the defendant who failed to keep a proper lookout and failed to maintain proper control of his vehicle. The defendant admitted liability. The plaintiff’s award was from the first and second defendants only. The jury returned a Plaintiff verdict.
Location: Pima County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Hall v. Foltz, c2006-0276
Type of Injury: Back injury-nerve damage
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $20,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff’s vehicle was struck in the rear in a three motor vehicle accident. Plaintiff sued Defendants seeking to recover for the injuries sustained in the collision. Compulsory arbitration occurred and the arbitrator determined that Defendant driver was 100% at fault, awarded Plaintiff $ 29,653.70 and costs were taxed against Defendants in the amount of $ 499.00. Defendants filed a notice of appeal and sought a trial de novo. Jury rendered a verdict in favor of Plaintiff and found that Defendant driver was entirely at fault. Co-defendant was awarded $15,425.00 for attorney’s fees, costs, and expert witness fees against Defendant driver.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Fisher v. Edgerton, CV2011-091831
Type of Injury: Whiplash-neck, shoulder pain and headaches
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $20,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff reportedly brought her van to a complete stop when the vehicle was struck from behind by a Discount Cab driven by Defendant. Plaintiff filed suit alleging Defendant drove Discount Cab’s vehicle in a careless, negligent and reckless manner and failed to control his speed to avoid a collision. The plaintiff sought damages for physical injuries, anxiety, pain and suffering and medical expenses. The defendants admitted an accident occurred but disputed the nature, extent and duration of the plaintiff’s injuries and damages. Jury returned a Plaintiff verdict.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Kimbrell v. Mohamed, CV2006-019419
Type of Injury: Neck injuries
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $20,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff was driving on West Greenway Parkway in Scottsdale, Ariz., June 22, 2001. Defendant was driving on Tierra Buena Lane. As Defendant turned onto Greenway from Tierra Buena, he allegedly struck the front passenger side of Plaintiff’s car. Plaintiff and her husband sued Defendant and his wife blaming Defendant for causing permanent nerve damage to her back, which required several operations, physical therapy and constant medication. Defendant admitted that his negligence contributed to the cause of the accident but denying that he failed to yield the right of way. The jury reached a verdict in favor of Plaintiffs.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Short v. Petty, CV2003-010701
Type of Injury: Head injuries-neck contusions
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $20,000
Case Summary: A rear-end collision occurred at the intersection of Dobson Road and Southern Avenue in Mesa, Ariz. Plaintiff said she was driving her 2000 Lexus sedan with her two granddaughters, minors J.A. and J.R., as passengers. The Lexus was was stopped at red light when it was rear-ended by Defendant. The police cited Defendant for “failure to avoid a collision,” and he later admitted fault. Plaintiffs filed a lawsuit against Defendants alleging Defendant’s negligent driving caused Plaintiff and her passengers to suffer physical and mental injuries. The jury returned three verdicts for the plaintiffs: Plaintiff driver was awarded $3,000 for damages, while J.A. received $20,000 and J.R. received $7,500.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Smith v. Black, CV2002-007569
Type of Injury: Back injuries-Back sprains
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $20,853
Case Summary: A collision between a 1999 Lexus GS 400 and a 1994 Toyota pickup truck occurred at the intersection of Mesa Drive and Auto Center Drive in Maricopa County, Ariz. According to Plaintiff, the operator of the Toyota, he was traveling south on Mesa when Defendant, the driver of the Lexus, turned left onto Auto Center from the northbound lanes of Mesa and caused the accident. Plaintiff and his wife sued Defendant claiming the Toyota was totaled leaving them with $5,788 in economic losses. In response, Defendant offered a different account of events, saying the Toyota collided with his vehicle. Jury returned a verdict for the plaintiffs.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Morris v. Johnson, CV2003-019341
Type of Injury: Back injuries- back and neck pain, cervical lumbar and rotator strains; right shoulder pain.
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $24,350
Case Summary: Plaintiff was driving his vehicle near the intersection of Ina Road and Camino De Law Tierra. In Plaintiff’s vehicle were two passengers. Defendant who was driving in the same area allegedly collided with Plaintiff’s vehicle. Passenger 1 purportedly suffered contusions. Passenger 2 claimed the accident caused neck injuries. Plaintiff alleged he incurred unspecified “physical, emotional and financial burdens.” Plaintiffs filed a lawsuit against Defendant for negligent driving. The defendant admitted she was involved in the accident but denied liability. The jury returned a verdict for plaintiffs awarding Passenger 1 $23,600 in damages and Plaintiff $750. Judge also awarded the plaintiffs $493.90 in costs.
Location: Pima County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Gonzales v. Price, C20011664
Type of Injury: Back Injury- Cervical spine strain; shoulder pain
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $25,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff was stopped at the intersection of E. Broadway Boulevard and Harrison in Tucson, Ariz., when his vehicle was rear-ended. Defendant drove the other vehicle and admitted fault for the accident. Plaintiff filed a complaint claiming Defendant’s negligent driving caused his injuries and subsequent medical expenses and other damages. In her answer Defendant contested the plaintiff’s alleged injuries. She also said Plaintiff failed to state a cause of action, which prohibits him from receiving prejudgment interest. The jury returned a verdict for the plaintiff. The Judge confirmed the verdict and added more than $4,800 in costs to the plaintiff’s award.
Location: Pima County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Weber v. Barnett, C20035247
Type of Injury: Back injuries-low back pain, neck pain; right shoulder pain; Head injuries-headaches, and mild traumatic brain injury
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $25,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff sued Defendant for injuries sustained in a phoenix motor vehicle accident that occurred at the intersection of Yorkshire Drive and 27th Avenue. Plaintiff accused Defendant of negligence. Plaintiff and his wife sought recovery for Plaintiff’s allegedly disabling and permanent injuries, pain, suffering, inconvenience, lost enjoyment of life, more than $12,000 medical and related expenses, lost earnings and lost earning capacity. Defendant admitted fault for the accident but denied Plaintiff sustained injuries and included affirmative defenses of failure to mitigate damages, lack of subject matter jurisdiction, statute of limitations, assumption of risk and contributory negligence. Jury returned a Plaintiff’s verdict.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Valerius v. Rosenberg, CV 2004-002183
Type of Injury: Back injuries-cervical spine strain
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $37,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff, the driver of a 2001 Toyota sport utility vehicle said he was driving west on Cactus with his wife as a passenger. Defendant who was driving a 1999 Dodge pickup truck behind the Toyota, “failed to maintain a safe distance between his vehicle and the Toyota,” and “recklessly slammed” into the Toyota, Plaintiff said. Plaintiff filed a complaint alleging Defendant’s negligent driving caused their injuries. Defendant filed an answer, denying liability. Prior to the verdict Plaintiff was dismissed from the action. Jury found for Plaintiff’s wife. The panel apportioned fault between Defendant, 65 percent, and the unidentified Crown Victoria driver, 35 percent.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Katz v. Manson, CV2003-022028
Type of Injury: Back injuries-soft tissue
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $37,000
Case Summary: Two vehicles collided at the intersection of N. 32nd Street and East Nisbett Road in Phoenix, April 7, 2003. According to Plaintiff, Defendant disobeyed a red traffic signal and caused a collision with his vehicle. Defendant disagreed, saying it was Plaintiff who ran a red light. Plaintiff filed a lawsuit against claiming the defendant breached a duty to operate her vehicle in a safe manner. The defendant admitting owing a duty to the plaintiff and other motorists but denied she breached said duty because Plaintiff was negligent motorist who failed to stop for a red light. A jury found in favour of the Plaintiff. Jurors apportioned liability 10% to Plaintiff and 90% to Defendant.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Dalrymple v. Hammel, CV2003-018994
Severe car accident injuries will have long-term effects on the victim that may include permanent disabilities. Severe injuries include brain trauma, complicated fractures, internal damage, amputations, and significant neck and back injuries, including spinal cord damage.
Type of Injury: Back injury-desiccated disc.
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $40,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff was a backseat passenger in Defendant’s vehicle when a collision occurred. The incident left Plaintiff with personal injuries, monetary losses, including medical expenses and lost income, she said. Plaintiff sued both drivers Defendants were responsible for the accident and the plaintiff’s subsequent losses. Filing a response, Defendants admitted the accident occurred but denied fault. Jurors found for the plaintiff and apportioned liability of 10% to Plaintiff (not wearing seat belt) and 90% to defendants. Based on the fault apportionment, Judge reduced Plaintiff’s award to $38,000, allocating each defendant pay half that amount. Judge added more than $2,600 in taxable costs to the plaintiff’s award.
Location: Pima County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Pender v. Slade, C20035903
Type of Injury: Back injury, collapsed lungs and lacerated liver
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $40,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff was riding his Honda motorcycle when Defendant collided into him. After being hit, Plaintiff claimed he was thrown to the ground and lost consciousness, regained consciousness while still in the road but blood “gushing from his mouth” made it difficult to breathe. According to Plaintiff, he was taken to Hospital’s emergency room where X-rays revealed a broken rib that had punctured his lung and that his right upper lip was “ripped open” and he suffered multiple bruises and abrasions. Plaintiff sued Defendant for gross negligent in her driving, which caused the accident and his injuries. Defendant admitted an accident occurred but denied culpability. Jury returned a Plaintiff verdict.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Wilson v. Jones, CV2003-020298
Type of Injury: Back Injuries-cervical radiculopathy and neck; arm tingling, hand numbness.
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $40,087
Case Summary: At the intersection of Alma School Road and Germann Road in Chandler, Ariz., a pickup truck and a tractor trailer collided. Plaintiff claiming the defendant’s negligent driving caused the accident. The plaintiff said he suffered “grievous bodily injuries,” including disabilities and impairments to his person; subsequent medical expenses; lost wages; and personal property damages as a result of the accident. The defendant admitted said accident occurred but denied it was caused by her negligence. Although the plaintiff could have suffered injuries from the subject collision, Defendant said, she was without sufficient information to confirm Plaintiff’s claimed damages. The jury returned a verdict for the plaintiff.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Anderson v. Vasquez, CV2001-018544
Type of Injury: Back injury-Cervical disc protrusions at C5-6 and C6-7
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $55,000
Case Summary: The Defendant insurance company failed to pay the 27-year-old female Plaintiff’s underinsured motorist claim for damages due to a rear-end motor vehicle accident. The Plaintiff said the insurer was acting in bad faith and the Defendant contested the Plaintiff’s claimed injuries and damages. The Plaintiff and defense experts agreed that the Plaintiff received soft tissue injuries, but disagreed that her ongoing pain was a result of the accident. Jury found in favor of Plaintiff.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Parker v. Allstate Insurance, 2008-053109
Type of Injury: Head injuries- brain damage & memory loss; Broken rib, punctured lung.
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $60,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff was driving south and uphill on Colossal Cave Road near Cienega High School when a collision resulted between her car and a truck driven by Defendant. Claiming Defendant violated State law, failure to yield when making a left turn, Plaintiff and his wife sued Defendant alleging that Plaintiff sought medical treatment for two years after the accident before he had rotator cuff surgery. Plaintiffs requested compensation for their damages, including medical expenses of $20,000 and his lost income. Defendant denied the plaintiffs’ allegations and claimed comparative negligence as an affirmative defense. A Superior Court jury returned a verdict for the plaintiffs.
Location: Pima County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Hartke v. Gall, C20042925
Type of Injury: Shoulder Injury-rotator cuff surgery
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $64,567
Case Summary: Plaintiff was riding her bicycle and as she moved along the designated bike lane, she approached a red traffic signal. The light turned green and Plaintiff attempted to continue north. Defendant turned right and the two vehicles collided. Plaintiff sued Defendant arguing that Defendant failed to yield the right of way. Defendant argued Plaintiff was solely responsible because her bicycle did not have a light visible from 500 feet away, in violation of state law. Before trial, the parties stipulated to a high/low arrangement of $75,000/ $35,000 for any jury verdict award. Jury apportioned fault in between the suggested amounts, resting 65% with Plaintiff and 35 percent with Defendant and awarded the plaintiff $64,567 in damages
Location: Pima County, Arizona
Case Name and Docket Number: Treadwell v. Rosenthal, C20053255
Type of Injury: Head injuries-broken nose; Hand injuries- left elbow and left ring finger; road rash
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $65,000
Case Summary: “A motor-vehicle collision ensued between a car driven southbound by Plaintiff and an eastbound Yellow Cab/Checker Cab owned and operated by Defendant on June 4, 2000. The plaintiff alleged Defendant’s negligent and careless driving resulted in the 1995 yellow Ford cab hitting her vehicle. Plaintiff sued the Cab Companies for negligent entrustment. Plaintiff said the collision caused her to suffer a desiccated disc, personal injuries and medical expenses. Defendant denied negligence and alleged Plaintiff was at fault. Defendant also disputed the nature and extent of the plaintiff’s injuries. The jury returned a Plaintiff verdict.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Parker v. Rhodes, CV-2001-009459
Type of Injury: Back injuries-lumbar and cervical discs injuries; Partial right shoulder rotator cuff tear.
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $75,000
Case Summary: Defendant was driving a Ford truck when he allegedly rear-ended a Dodge van driven by Plaintiff, which was stopped for traffic. The force of impact allegedly caused the van to rear-end a semi-truck stopped before it. All three vehicles were southbound on North 51st at the time. Plaintiff filed suit against Defendant, his employer and the owner of the Ford truck, claiming Defendant’s negligent driving caused the accident and the plaintiff’s injuries. In their answer, the defendants denied the allegations. They asserted the affirmative defenses of third party, comparative and contributory negligence, and that Plaintiff’s injuries could have been from a pre-existing injury. Jury returned a verdict in favor of Plaintiff.
Location: Maricopa County-Arizona
Case Name and Docket Number: Diaz v. Allshouse, CV2003-006821
Type of Injury: Leg injury-fractures of tibia and fibula
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $102,000
Case Summary: The Plaintiff was a male on a motorcycle traveling eastbound behind was a vehicle driven by Defendant. After stopping at a red light, both Defendant and Plaintiff made right turns into the southbound curb lane. Plaintiff then moved into the median lane. When Defendant moved into the median lane, the motorcycle and the vehicle collided. Plaintiff suffered right leg fractures in the area of his distal tibia and fibula. Plaintiff filed a complaint against Defendant. Defendant denied liability. Jury returned a plaintiff verdict. The Judge reduced award to $102,000 based on the jury’s fault apportionment of 51%: 49%. Plaintiff also awarded $949.65 for costs.
Location: Tucson, Pima County, Arizona
Case Name and Docket Number: Caves v. Wheels Inc., C 2002 3176
Type of Injury: Head injuries-Lacerations and scarring to face; Leg injuries-broken leg; Back & neck injuries
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $111,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff 1 was driving a station wagon when Defendant, driving a vehicle eastbound on Weldon Avenue reportedly failed to yield at a stop sign and collided with Plaintiff 1’s vehicle. Plaintiff 1 claimed he sustained lacerations and scarring of his face, legs and back injuries while Plaintiff 2 broke his leg as a result of the collision. Plaintiffs sued Defendant alleging the collision occurred as a result of Defendant’s recklessness. Defendant admitted fault but alleged Plaintiff 1 was comparatively negligent. A jury found in favor of plaintiffs and apportioned liability: 60% to Plaintiff 2 (for failure to use seatbelt), 10% to Defendant and 30 percent to Plaintiff 1.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Gamboa v. Metzler, CV2004-018656
Type of Injury: Back injuries-cervical, spine and lumbar
Type of Accident: Rear-End
Award/Settlement Amount: $177,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff was driving his Ford pickup truck east on Bell Road in Phoenix. He was stopped when Defendant, driving an Isuzu truck, struck Plaintiff’s vehicle from the rear. Plaintiff said he sustained personal injuries as a result. Plaintiff filed suit against Defendant and his employer claiming his personal injuries were the direct result of Defendant’s negligence. The plaintiff requested damages for medical expenses and past and future lost wages. His wife claimed loss of consortium. In his answer, Defendant admitted that he hit the back of Plaintiff’s pickup truck but denied that his actions proximately caused plaintiff’s injuries and damages. Jury returned a Plaintiff verdict
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Porak v. Rodriguez, CV2002-024991
Type of Injury: Back injuries-spinal discs damage
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $200,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff sued Defendants alleging that he suffered an aggravation to pre-existing degenerative disc disease when his vehicle collided with the defendant’s vehicle. The plaintiff contended that defendant operated his vehicle in a negligent manner, failed to keep a proper lookout, made a U-turn when it was unsafe to do so, and drove under the influence of alcohol. The defendant admitted liability but disputed the nature and extent of the plaintiff’s injuries. Jury returned a Plaintiff verdict, apportioned 70% fault to driver and 30 percent to wife (co-Defendant). Defendants appealed. Court of Appeals held that the proper reallocation of fault was 100% percent to Defendant driver.
Location: Pima County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Cuna v. Kroack, C20034274
Type of Injury: Leg injuries-comminuted right proximal tibial fracture.
Type of Accident: Single Vehicle
Award/Settlement Amount: $280,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff was riding his motorcycle when the road surface changed from asphalt to gravel and dirt. Plaintiff stated that the motorcycle lost traction and he “wrecked and crashed to the ground.” Plaintiff alleged he sustained a lower leg fracture and incurred medical expenses and lost wages. He sued Maricopa County claiming the county negligently left the roadway in an uneven and hazardous condition and failed to warn motorists of the change in the road surface.The plaintiff requested general and special damages, among other reliefs. The county denied liability claiming contributory negligence, among other affirmative defenses. The Maricopa County Superior Court jury returned a verdict for Plaintiff.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Nichols v. Maricopa County, V2003-015918
Type of Injury: Leg injury-amputation of lower right leg
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $1,670,000
Case Summary: Plaintiff was driving a pickup when Defendant, allegedly intoxicated failed to stop for a red traffic signal and struck Plaintiff’s pickup in the intersection. Plaintiff allegedly suffered injuries that required his lower right leg to be amputated. Plaintiff filed a lawsuit claiming Defendant failed to stop for a red traffic signal in violation of State law. Plaintiff’s wife joined the lawsuit claiming loss of consortium. A jury awarded $770,000 to Plaintiff and $150,000 to his wife. The panel attributed 65 percent of total negligence to owners of the Bar where Defendant had been drinking and 35 percent to Defendant. The jury also awarded Plaintiff $750,000 in punitive damages against bar owner.
Location: Maricopa County, Arizona.
Case Name and Docket Number: Miranda v. Villanueva, CV2006-015210
Type of Injury: Back injury-incomplete cervical spinal cord injury
Type of Accident: Side-Impact
Award/Settlement Amount: $7,225,000
Case Summary: A motor vehicle accident between an 18-wheel dump truck, driven by the Defendant and a motorcycle, driven by the Plaintiff allegedly occurred on March 14, 2003, at the intersection of Alvernon Way and Irvington Road in Pima County. Plaintiff filed suit claiming Defendant’s negligent driving caused him to suffer “incomplete cervical spinal cord injury” and required a wheelchair for mobility. Plaintiff’s wife filed a claim for loss of consortium. In their answer, Defendants denied the plaintiffs’ claims and moved to dismiss the complaint. The judge reduced Plaintiff’s award to $7,225,000.00 and award for loss of consortium to $212,500.00 after the jury apportioned fault between the parties 85%:15%.
Location: Pima County, Arizona
Case Name and Docket Number: Storm v. Yocum, C2003-2281
We analyzed a group of actual Arizona lawsuits filed by injured car accident victims. All plaintiffs in the group received compensation from a jury award or by settling with the defendant before trial.
In cases with more than one plaintiff, the “Award/Settlement Amount” reflects the highest payout to an individual plaintiff. The Award amount also reflects any reduction applied for shared fault.
(Your submission is secure and is kept strictly confidential.)
